5 Best Mulch For Weed Control Reviews in 2024 – Buying Guide & FAQ

Mulch is a material used to cover the soil surface around plants, trees, and other outdoor plants. But in many cases, it is used for weed control, by keeping weeds from growing and deterring bad insects while keeping/attracting the beneficial insects.

There are many different mulches available on the market that qualify as being the best mulch for weed control. These include Cocoa Shells, Bark Chips, or Pine Straws. The issue that you may face is finding the top mulch for weed control among the thousands of products available on the marketplace.

This is why we have researched, tested, and shortlisted mulches that you can use in your garden to stop the invasion of weeds.

5 Best Mulch For Weed Control Reviews in 2024

#1. National Cocoa Shell Mulch To Control Weeds In Vegetable Gardens – Best Overall

Weeds can get really annoying in your garden or yard and you need the best mulch for weed control.

We think the title goes to the National Cocoa Shell Mulch as it just does an exceptional job of making sure no junk weeds grow in your soil and that your soil gets all of the moisture and water it needs to thrive.

It is also priced quite reasonably and great bang for the buck.

National Cocoa Shell Mulch is a new, all-natural weed control alternative that is made from the shells of cocoa beans.

It is a finely ground mulch that is colored black and has a little bit of chocolate smell.

National Cocoa Shell Mulch can be used to control weeds in flower beds, gardens, and around trees and shrubs.

It is safe for use around children and pets and can be applied up to the day of harvest.

So, when it comes to the best mulch for weed control, we highly recommend that you try out the National Cocoa Shell Mulch.

This mulch has a really nice brown color and cocoa bean shells. For some reason, cocoa bean shells just do a superior job of keeping the weeds out as well as all sorts of unwanted pests. Nothing will grow in your soil except the pure goodness that you planted.

It goes without saying that the water retention of these cocoa shells is pretty good and it never lets your soil get overly soggy during heavy rain or if you overwater. Overall, this is a really good bang for the buck.


  • Keeps weeds out
  • Regulate temperature
  • A nice aesthetic visual look
  • Increase plant yields
  • Brown color and organic


  • A bit expensive
  • Can be toxic for dogs

View on Amazon

#2. EZ-Straw Seeding Mulch Prevents Weeds From Growing – Best Mulch For Beginners

EZ-Straw Seeding Mulch is a straw product that is designed to control weeds.

The product is made of chopped straw that is then treated with a little tiny amount of weed killer.

It can be used as a mulch to cover the ground around plants or it can be used as a seeding mulch to help new plants grow.

We decided to put this mulch in second place as it is also one of the best mulch for weed control if you are trying to protect seeds or just growing a new lawn.

This is a pure organic straw. It has been nicely processed and clumped together using a bonding agent, which makes it harder to just be blown away by the wind.

It really keeps the weeds out of whatever you are trying to grow and protects your seeds well.

Also, it helps greatly speed up germination, which is the main reason people get this. All in all, this straw mulch is very non-toxic and safe for kids and pets, even though it has some particulate weed control bits.

It really does keep the weeds at bay and does a whole bunch of other good stuff for your garden.


  • Improve your plant roots and your pot soil’s moisture
  • Processed straw is easy to apply
  • Its tackifier properties improve the germination
  • Enhance the germination and growth of your seeds
  • Comes with a UV-resistance plastic bag so that you can store your bag outside
  • The mulch decomposes through time and is biodegradable.
  • Help control soil temperature


  • Can fly away with strong winds

View on Amazon

#3. Oldcastle Black Mulch For Weed Control – Best Inorganic

When most people think of mulch, they think of the dark, rich color it adds to their flower beds and gardens.

What they may not know is that there are different types of mulch, each with its own unique benefits.

One such type is black mulch. Black mulch is made from recycled rubber tires and is a great way to control weeds in your garden.

So this is another really nice option when it comes to the best mulch for weed control.

This is a traditional black mulch done right with a great amount of black.

The standout feature here is definitely the color, which really makes your garden pop out. It has that jet-black look and it doesn’t fade for at least 12 months.

Needless to say, the weed control is pretty good here and it also helps moderate soil temperature and helps your soil absorb more nutrients, which is always a good thing.

Although it is a little pricey, we think that it is well worth it in the end if you are going for all of the premium quality ingredients without any fillers or artificial ingredients.


  • Attractive to the eye
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • A great cover for soil insulation
  • Keep soil moist
  • Effective in controlling weeds
  • Color does not fade for at least a year


  • Inorganic material

View on Amazon

#4. Hoffman Peat Moss For Weed Control – Best Water Control

Maintaining a weed-free garden is an ongoing challenge for any homeowner.

Weeds can take over a garden quickly, and before you know it, you’re fighting a losing battle against these pesky plants.

There are many methods for controlling weeds, but one of the most effective is using Hoffman peat moss

The Hoffman Peat Moss is excellent for weed control and is definitely a mulch that everybody should just have around if they are trying to do any serious gardening.

So you basically have to mix this with soil to get the full effects and it definitely does a great job of increasing the soil’s water retention as well as the retention of quality ingredients.

Although weed control is pretty good with this product, we think the above-mentioned products are better. This peat moss shines in other aspects such as water retention.

Additionally, many people really like it because it prevents bugs, termites, and other pests from getting into your soil, which can be a lifesaver.


  • Help water retention
  • Weeds free
  • Reduce molds
  • Good at fighting moss
  • Look nice in the garden


  • May be too acidic for non-acid-loving plants
  • Low in nutrients so you need a fertilizer

View on Amazon

#5. USA Pine Straw Mulch For Weed Control – Best Pine Needles

mulch for weed controlAs the name suggests, pine straw mulch is made of pine needles.

It is a popular organic mulch for weed control and water conservation in home gardens and landscapes.

Pine straw mulch has a high acidity that helps to suppress weeds by inhibiting their growth. It also attracts earthworms, which help to aerate the soil and improve its structure.

Though we have left the straw as our last mulch, the USA Pine Straw Mulch provides really good mulch for all planting beds and gardens and definitely keeps the weeds out.

It is widely known that pine straw clearly helps keeps weeds away, but another great thing about this pine straw is that it doesn’t smell or make your garden stink.

Also, it is good at preventing bugs, pests, and even dust from collecting in your soil, which can gnaw at roots and really ruin a perfectly good garden.

The only thing you have to get over is the fact that it doesn’t really look that good in your garden and won’t have that black mulch vibrant look.


  • Good water retention
  • Great weed suppression
  • Nicely packed
  • No seeds
  • Great at preventing bugs and pets


  • Mayfly away if not laid properly

View on Amazon

Final Verdict

Mulching can be an important part of weed control. That’s why there are a variety of mulches that have been produced specifically for this purpose.

The five mulches described above can all be used to keep weeds at bay, and each one has its own benefits.

Our favorite is the National Cocoa Shell Mulch because it also has that little chocolaty flavor to it. So if you like that little flavor, then look no further. This product is for you.

What to consider when choosing the best mulch to prevent weeds – Buyer’s Guide

There are a few things to consider when choosing mulch for weed prevention. The main point you want to take care of is light. You need to make 100% sure that it will block out light so that weeds can’t grow. That is the only main point.

Now other things to consider are as follows.

For organic mulch:

  • You want to choose a mulch that will add nutrients to the soil as it breaks down – this will help your plants grow strong and prevent weeds from taking over.
  • There is a need for mulch that provides a barrier against heat in summer and cold in winter.
  • You need a mulch that is good at water retention.
  • Bad pets and insects are difficult to get rid of, but there are organic mulches that have embedded insect and pet-repellent scents. So if you are in an area with bad insects, select the right mulch and you’ll automatically reduce half of your problems.

For inorganic mulch:

  • You definitely need to choose the right inorganic mulch material for the right application based on the look you want, the location of the garden, the type of soil, if it is a vegetable garden, a fruit tree garden, or a landscape, and the season.
  • Take wood chips or rubber mulch for weed control for playgrounds.
  • Take plastic or fabric mulch for planting plants that like heat and require water retention.
  • Enjoy the visual aspect of white stones or shredded redwood for a new landscape and weed control.

As you can see, all of the above mulches will help you control weeds. It is the quality of your soil and your application that will dictate if you use organic or non-organic mulch solutions.

FAQ – Frequently Asked Question

Is mulch good for weed control?

Yes, mulch is an effective way to prevent weeds from taking root in your garden or landscape. It is a material that is placed on top of the soil to suppress weed growth. In essence, it limits the light required for weeds to start germinating and growing. Note that choosing the right mulch is really important. The reason is that some mulch may contain seeds, and as such you may end up with more weeds in your garden compared to before applying the mulch.

What type of mulch is best to prevent weeds?

As any gardener knows, one of the most important things to do in order to have a healthy garden is to prevent weeds from taking over. But with so many different types of mulch available, it can be difficult to know which one is best for weed prevention.

Basically, mulch is a material that is placed on top of the soil to improve the health of the plants and/or enhance the appearance of the landscape. There are many different types of mulch available to consumers, each with its own set of benefits. However, these mulches can be divided into two main groups: inorganic and organic mulch.

Inorganic mulches, such as landscape fabrics, recycled rubber mulch, stone mulch, pebbles, and gravel, can prevent weed growth. However, they will not add extra nutrients to the soil as they do not decompose.

Organic mulches, such as bark, wood chips, and leaves, help the soil hold needed moisture, add nutrients to the soil, reduce soil erosion on hills and graded lands, and keep flowers, fruits, and vegetables clean.

There is no such thing as the best mulch to prevent weeds. All of the mulches can do this. However, choosing the type of mulch is important. You need to define if you will be using mulch for landscaping (making your land look beautiful and appealing to the eye), or to plant flowers, vegetables, and fruit trees.

As a basic rule of thumb, if you want to improve the look of your garden, then inorganic mulch is best. If you want to add nutrients to your plants, then organic should be your top choice.

How many times a year do you need to mulch your vegetable garden to prevent weeds?

The right layer of garden mulch is key to a successful weed-free vegetable garden. So, the questions one should ask are “How thick should the weed barrier be? And how often should you apply it?”

A layer of mulch 2 to 3 inches deep will prevent most weeds from taking root. In fact, professional gardeners’ advice is to have a 3-inch layer. Such a layer will ensure that there is no light reaching the soil and as such no weed will germinate.

Professional gardeners also advise applying a fresh layer of mulch on your garden bed every year if it is wood chips like bark mulch. Wood chips are a perennial solution if you know what you do with them compared to other organic mulch. If you are using some simple composts or grass clippings, then it is best to add mulch every 4 to 6 weeks, or as needed to discourage weeds and warm the soil in early spring. Note that you need to be careful when using grass clippings. You need to check that there are no weed seeds in the bags you buy (just check the packaging, there should be a note on this matter).

Note that mulching also helps retain moisture in the soil and keeps fruit tree stems and vegetables clean. So don’t be greedy on the mulch for your yard! A little extra effort and a couple of inches of mulch now will pay off later in a bountiful harvest.




The Review Gurus